Sorting through the vast array pet products on the market shelves can be an overwhelming task for anyone, and we know how picky our feline friends can be! For those of us who choose to go the organic way, there are several factors to consider when shopping for organic cat food.

We looked at dozens of organic brands to find the best of the best, based on a careful review of ingredients, cost, Amazon ratings, and more.

All of these brands are reputable and proven, and if you find a brand your cat likes (and eats!) stick with it! Indoor cats generally don’t drink enough water, so it is important to get as much moisture into their diets as possible.

With that being said, we narrowed our search down to what we believe are the 10 best natural and organic cat foods.

Top 10 Organic Cat Food Brands: Comparison Table

How We Reviewed the Organic Cat Food Brands

We reviewed the following organic cat foods based on Amazon customer reviews, nutritional balance, ingredients, variety of flavors and cost. Generally, the more expensive the brand, the higher the quality but most reviewed brands are worth the cost.

Top 10 Organic Cat Food Brands

Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein, Natural Adult Dry Cat Food, Duck 11-lb
  • PACKED WITH REAL DUCK: Made to feed your feline's wild side, this high protein cat food is packed with more of the duck cats crave to help build and maintain lean muscle mass
  • GRAIN FREE CAT FOOD: BLUE Wilderness grain free adult cat food is made with healthy carbohydrates including sweet potatoes and peas to help fuel your cat's active lifestyle; Plus, it contains omega 3 & 6 fatty acids to support skin and coat health
  • WITH LIFESOURCE BITS: This formula contains BLUE's exclusive LifeSource Bits - a precise blend of antioxidants, vitamins and minerals carefully selected by holistic veterinarians and animal nutritionists, to support immune system health

BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Adult Dry Cat Food

Inspired by the diets of wildcats, this top brand has 5 varieties of flavors, none of which contain corn, wheat, soy or by-products.

Available flavors are Chicken Grain Free, Chicken Weight Control, Indoor Chicken Formula, Chicken Weight Control & Hairball Formula, and Duck.

organic cat food - BLUE Wilderness High Protein Grain Free Adult Dry Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

At least 36% of its recipe is comprised of crude protein and 12% crude fat – a healthy balance which provides nutrients while maintaining a healthy body weight. Also included are Omega-3s and Omega-6s which promote healthy skin and a shiny coat.

Pros

+ Great nutritional balance of protein and fat

+ Always lists meat at the first ingredient

+ Wide variety of flavors

Cons

Cost

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.5

$

4.5

Newman’s Own Premium Canned Formulas for Cats (with Organic Ingredients)

Ranking in the top of our wet food choices, Newman’s high-quality organic canned cat food is sourced from premium meats.

organic cat food - Newman's Own Premium Canned Formulas for Cats (with Organic Ingredients) as one of the best organic cat food

Newman's Own Premium, Turkey Formula for Cats, 5.5-Ounce Cans (Pack of 24)
  • Made In The Usa
  • A Professionally Developed Recipe Containing Organic Turkey As The First Ingredient
  • No Artificial Flavors, Colors Or Preservatives; No Wheat Or Corn

Available in four flavors without harmful by-products, preservatives, corn or wheat. In all of their flavors, the first and primary ingredient is meat. 

Current flavors are Chicken & Brown Rice, Chicken & Salmon, Turkey, and Turkey & Vegetables.

Pros

+ The primary ingredient is meat

+ Cats love the flavor, according to           Amazon reviews

Cons

Though the main ingredients are             organic, this cat food isn’t exclusively     organic. About 70%

Recent reviews on Amazon have             indicated problems with packaging           and/or delivery

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.0

$

4.0

Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dry Cat Food

An ideal solution for cats who require a limited diet, whether due to food sensitives, intolerances, allergies, or digestive issues.

Each variety has a limited list of natural ingredients – an animal protein, rounded out by pea protein and healthy fats –  but manages to deliver the nutrients necessary to maintain optimal feline health, a shiny coat, and healthy digestion. 100% grain free. 

organic cat food - Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dry Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dry Cat Food, Green Pea & Duck Formula, 10 Pounds, Grain Free
  • Contains (1) 5 pound bag of dry cat food
  • Grain-free, limited ingredient diet with a single animal protein source
  • Helps minimize the number of ingredients cats are exposed to

Available in four flavors: Green Pea & Chicken, Green Pea & Duck, Green Pea & Salmon, and Green Pea & Venison.

Pros

+ Cost is affordable

+ 100% grain-free, limited ingredient diet provides balanced nutrition for cats         at all stages of life

+ Contains no artificial flavors or bleached ingredients

Cons

Packaging states that it is “packaged   in  California,” but it is unclear where       the ingredients originate

Certain picky felines may turn their         noses at the lack of strong flavor

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.0

$

4.0

Organix Grain Free Organic Cat Food

Ideal for kitties on a grain-free diet. A blend of organic chicken, organic peas, organic potatoes and organic lentils delivers a full nutritional profile, without grains, corn, wheat, soy or fillers.

Available in one flavor, which consists of real organic chicken as the #1 ingredient, packing a punch of 34% protein.

organic cat food - Organix Grain Free Organic Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

ORGANIX Grain Free Organic Chicken & Sweet Potato Recipe Dry Cat Food - 10 lb. Bag
  • #1 Ingredient Is Organic, Free-Range Chicken
  • Made With A Nutrient Packed Superfood Blend Featuring Organic Flaxseed, Organic Cranberries And Organic Coconut Oil
  • No Artificial Preservatives, Added Growth Hormones Or Antibiotics

Also features organic peas, organic potatoes, and organic lentils. No corn, soy or wheat. A modified recipe is available for each stage of your cat’s life: Kitten, Adult, and Senior.

Pros

+ Produced without chemical pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, antibiotics, or added growth hormones

+ Boasts the label of Amazon’s choice   for “Organix Cat Food” with a                     customer rating of 4.1 stars

Cons

  Cost is steep for dry food

  Only one flavor available

  Certain finicky felines may not like the taste, according to recent customer         reviews 

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.1

$

4.1

Rachael Ray’s Nutrish Natural Dry Cat Food

This super affordable choice is a customer favorite for its nutritional value as well as for the cause it supports.

Sourced from farm-raised chicken, hearty brown rice, and plenty of vegetables, a portion of the proceeds go to Rachael’s Rescue, a charity that has donated over $21 million to help pets in need. 

Available in two flavors: Chicken & Brown Rice, and Salmon & Brown Rice. 

organic cat food - Rachael Ray's Nutrish Natural Dry Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

No corn, wheat, soy, fillers, or poultry by-products, and no artificial flavors or preservatives.

Rachael Ray Nutrish Premium Natural Dry Cat Food, Real Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe, 3 Pounds
  • Contains (1) 3 Pound Bag of Dry Cat Food
  • Natural dry cat food recipe made with U.S. farm-raised chicken as the #1 ingredient
  • Includes wholesome brown rice, vegetables, and essential vitamins, minerals and amino acids

Pros

+ Affordable price

+ A portion of the proceeds go to           Rachael’s Rescue

Cons

  There have been a few recent customer complaints on the                       packaging

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.3

$

4.3

Nature’s Variety Instinct Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

A gluten-free, grain-free, high-protein dry cat food with a wholesome balance of nutrients. The outer coating is freeze-dried to seal in flavor and nutrients.

Available in five flavors: Chicken, Duck & Turkey, Rabbit, Duck and Turkey, and Salmon.

organic cat food - Nature’s Variety Instinct Grain-Free Dry Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

Instinct Original Grain Free Recipe with Real Chicken Natural Dry Cat Food by Nature's Variety, 2.2 lb. Bag
  • GRAIN FREE CAT FOOD WITH CAGE FREE CHICKEN: Instinct Original dry cat food is made with 81% real animal ingredients and nutritious oils, 19% vegetables, fruits and other wholesome ingredients. Responsibly sourced cage free chicken is the #1 ingredient.
  • NATURAL CAT FOOD: Instinct Original dry cat food is high protein cat food made with probiotics to support healthy digestion and omegas for skin & coat. Made without grain, potato, corn, wheat, soy, by-product meals, artificial colors or preservatives.
  • THE FIRST RAW COATED KIBBLE: Our grain free cat food offers balanced nutrition for all cats, including indoor & kittens. Each piece of kibble is coated in freeze dried raw for nutrition & taste. Delicious, healthy flavor that even picky kitties will love.

Pros

+ 100% grain-free

Cons

  Pricey

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.4

$

4.4

Purina Beyond Natural Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

This 100% grain-free, natural cat food contains the real fish, chicken, and eggs, as well as fresh veggies, and leaves out red flags like corn, wheat and soy.

Available in two flavors: Ocean Whitefish & Egg Recipe; and White Meat Chicken Recipe.

organic cat food - Purina Beyond Natural Grain-Free Dry Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

Purina Beyond Grain Free - Ocean Whitefish and Egg Recipe - 11 lb (16408)
  • One (1) 11 lb. Bag - Purina Beyond Grain Free, Natural Dry Cat Food, Simply Grain Free Ocean Whitefish & Egg Recipe
  • High protein cat food with real ocean whitefish as the #1 ingredient
  • Gluten and grain free, limited ingredient cat food with natural probiotics for digestive health

Pros

+ extremely affordable

Cons

  Limited choices in flavors

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.5

$

4.5

TAPA Natural Wet Grain Free Cat Food

The 100% grain-free, high-quality cat food comes packed in freshness-sealed packages.

All ingredients are 100% natural and human-grade, meaning it’s the quality of food you would eat yourself. 

organic cat food - TAPA Natural Wet Grain Free Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

Sa-Shi Grain Free Wet Cat Food Pouches 1.76oz. Five Flavors (Variety Pack)
  • SA-SHI Grain Free Wet Cat Food Pouch Variety Pack - 5 Flavors
  • Simply 4 Human-Grade Natual Ingredients
  • Grain Free, No Guar Gum, No Xanthan Gum, & No Carrageenan

Available in six flavors: Chicken Breast & Duck, Chicken Breast & Pumpkin, Chicken Breast & Cheese, Chicken Breast & Beef, Bonito Tuna & Shrimp, and Wild-Caught Salmon & Beef.

Pros

+ Grain-free

+ High in moisture content

Ingredients are human grade

+ 10% of profits are donated to help         service animals

Cons

  Of the few customer reviews, a few     had issues with packaging

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.5

$

4.5

Wellness CORE Natural Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

A dense and high-quality nutritional profile of proteins, probiotics, antioxidants, fatty acids, vitamins and minerals that cats need throughout all life stages. Available in four flavors.

organic cat food - Wellness CORE Natural Grain-Free Dry Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

Wellness CORE Grain-Free Original Formula Dry Cat Food, 11 Pound Bag
  • SAVORY FOOD CATS LOVE: Because cats naturally crave meat, each bite is packed with a high concentration of quality animal protein from turkey along with nutrient rich superfoods and added nutritional supplements for an amazing flavor cats love
  • ELEVATED NUTRITION FOR A LIFETIME OF WELLBEING: Wellness CORE pairs the best of science and natural; working with our staff of vets, nutritionists and scientists, we create each diet to deliver everything your cat needs to thrive, for a lifetime
  • WHOLE BODY HEALTH: This recipe is crafted to deliver everything your cat needs to be healthy; energy for playtime, a lustrous skin and coat, sound digestion and immunity, strong teeth and healthy eyes, plus controlled minerals for urinary health support

Pros

+ Four stars based on over 1400               customer reviews

+ 100% Grain free

Cons

  Price

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.5

$

4.5

Wellness TruFood Tasty Pairings Natural Grain Free Wet Raw-Inspired Cat Food

A raw-inspired, natural wet food with high-quality proteins and fresh vegetables, fortified with superfoods, vitamins, and minerals. Available in three flavors.

organic cat food - Wellness TruFood Tasty Pairings Natural Grain Free Wet Raw-Inspired Cat Food as one of the best organic cat food

Wellness Trufood Tasty Pairings Natural Grain Free Wet Raw Dog Food, Chicken, Pumpkin & Beef, 5-Ounce Cup (Pack Of 24)
  • Grain Free: Grain Free, Complete And Balanced Everyday Nutrition For Your Dog
  • Quality Ingredients: A Delicious Blend Of Diced Pure Proteins From Whole-Prey Chicken & Beef, Along Vitamin Rich Vegetables In A Chicken Broth Gravy
  • All Natural: Contains Only Premium, All Natural Ingredients With No Wheat, Artificial Colors, Flavors Or Preservatives

Pros

+ 100% grain-free

+ Easy-to-serve cups are individually         packed, for convenience

Cons

  Very hard to locate online, could be     discontinued

  No customer reviews on Amazon

Quality
Price
Our Rating

4.4

$

4.4

Product FAQ’s

organic cat food - British shorthair cat having organic cat food for snack

What is organic cat food?

A good rule of thumb is that organic cat food is produced without chemical pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, antibiotics, or added growth hormones. Cats are carnivores, and thrive on meat and nutrients found in natural resources.

Should you buy it?

If your kitty is prone to allergies, hair loss or digestive issues, organic may be the way to go. Organic foods typically have fewer ingredients which are inspected and held to a higher standard in order to be certified organic. These are the right option for anyone who’s particularly conscious of the environment in which their cat’s food is produced.

More importantly, organic food uses no chemical pesticides or synthetic fertilizers, and it doesn’t contain any GMOs.

What is better: Wet or Dry?

Though your vet will have the best answer for your cat’s individual needs, a combination of wet and dry appear to be the best way to balance moisture content with affordability. Wet cat food, though more expensive, has inherently more moisture, which is important for your cat’s bones and muscles. Dry cat food is more economical and is good for your kitty’s teeth.

You also don’t have to refrigerate unused portions of the dry food. You can get the benefits from both worlds by mixing them together.

Overall Price Range Of This Product

Prices are affordable for a bag of dry food, with canned wet food falling in the middle. Generally speaking, wet food is more expensive per ounce, making dry food more economical.

Since it’s extremely important to make sure your furry friend has plenty of moisture, adding wet food to the diet will help immeasurably. It’s best to purchase wet food in bulk, usually 24 cans to a box. You’ll end up paying cheap.

Individual pouches of cat food have become popular as well, and you’ll end up paying a smaller amount if you purchase in sets of 12.

Best Organic Cat Food: The Verdict

organic cat food - girl giving organic cat food to her pet

If you’re looking for balanced nutrition from an organic cat food combined with affordability, Rachael Ray’s Nutrish Natural Dry Cat Food comes out the clear winner.

At a small amount for a 6-pound bag, you’re also supporting Rachael’s Rescues through your purchase.  Some cats will simply not eat certain organic or natural dry foods which don’t have a strong flavor. This proved to be the case in certain customer reviews on Amazon.

One way to get around this is to add wet food to your cat’s diet, and there are a few good choices in the list above. And because cats need moisture, it’s best to combine dry food with wet. Newman’s Own Premium Canned Formulas for Cats is a good addition, and cats love the flavor. Although pricier per ounce, you also can’t go wrong with TAPA Natural Wet Grain-Free Cat Food.          

More on finding the best organic ingredients: 8 Best Organic Multivitamins for Men Reviewed | Best Organic Apple Cider Vinegar Reviewed | Organic Baby Food | Natural Shampoos for Kids 

Last update on 2021-09-17 at 01:00 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API