We have all heard the saying: “Milk, it does a body good!” Well, organic milk brands say their products can do a body even better. This is mainly because their milk comes from cows fed 100% organic feed with no added growth hormones or antibiotics.

This means you, the consumer, drink in less of the bad and more of the good nutrients your body craves.

However, not all organic milk brands are created equal. Ever since the rise in popularity of organic foods, there have been companies taking advantage of the organic label and putting products on grocery store shelves that are not truly organic.

Have no fear, though, there are some reliable, certified organic brands out there, particularly when it comes to milk.

This article will provide you with a thorough review of the top 7 best organic milk brands in an effort to help you decide and purchase only the best and most trustworthy products on the market today.

But before we dive into the comparisons, allow us to do a little FAQ. A well-informed consumer always makes the best purchase decisions.

You may check also these our other very popular organic articles “Baby organic products” and “Top organic sugar brands“.

Product FAQ’s

1. What Is Organic Milk?

organic alcohol

The FDA has defined organic milk as milk from a cow which has been treated with neither antibiotics nor growth or reproductive hormones.

It must also be at least 30 percent pasture-fed. Farmers living in temperate climates are required to allow their cows graze in a pasture for as long as possible, ensuring the cows get a minimum of 120 grazing days a year.

Conventional milk can be produced in the same way. The only difference between the two is that conventional milk is not held to the same standards as organic milk is.

2. Why Should I Switch to Organic Milk?

organic alcohol - lady drinking milk

Organic milk is better for your health, the cows, and the environment. Cows are shown to be much happier grazing and feeding on non-GMO and pesticide-free fodder as they naturally should.​

In order to become USDA Organic certified, U.S. organic milk producers must also maintain or improve upon the natural resources in their area, including the soil, wildlife, and water quality.

If that isn’t enough to grow your milk mustache, organic milk has higher levels of omega-3s fatty acids than its non-organic counterpart.

3. How Does It Work?

organic alcohol - a glass of milk

Because of stricter standards, organic milk must be certified to be sold as such. According to the USDA organic guidelines, any cow that has been treated with antibiotics at an organic dairy farm can no longer be milked for organic milk.

Antibiotics are usually administered to prevent mastitis — an infection in mammary gland tissue which can happen during lactation. The only solution is to separate cows with mastitis from the herd.

However, farmers have found ways to manage this problem, but those workarounds are not always healthy for the end consumer.

4. Where Can I Buy Organic Milk Brands?

organic alcohol - grocery with milk

Organic milk brands are widely available. You can find them in major supermarkets such as Pavilions, Vons, and Whole Foods as well as in specialty grocery chains like Trader Joe’s and Sprouts Farmers Market.

You can even find organic milk on Amazon or get it straight from the dairy farm itself. From your local store to your online grocery delivery service, this product is fairly easy to find.

5. Price Range

organic alcohol - price range

Prices of the seven brands we have reviewed range from $2.99-$5.15 per 1/2 gallon and $5.49-$7.49 per gallon. Remember, organic milk is more expensive than conventional milk, but its added benefits more than make up for the price difference.

How We Reviewed

To figure out which organic milk brands on the market are truly the cream of the crop, we’ve analyzed each of them objectively based on several factors, like ingredients, certifications, consumer feedback, and information from quality standard ratings set by the Cornucopia Institute.

This institute is a nonprofit small-farm advocacy group which does in-depth research and investigations on agricultural and food issues to educate both farmers and consumers, as well as the media.

To make the comparison useful, we set our own parameters on this list to include features, prices, pros and cons, and where to buy each product.

We have also classified the information we’ve gathered for each product through these parameters and ranked them in descending order.

Overall Price Range Of Organic Milk

Organic milk does tend to be pricier than conventional milk because it is much more expensive to produce. However, it is worth the extra $1.00.

You will not only be buying milk free of antibiotics, synthetic hormones, and toxic pesticides, but you will also be supporting healthy agriculture practices and your family’s long-term health and well-being.

Milk Brands We Reviewed

• Organic Valley• Clover• Stonyfield Farm• Trader Joe’s• Horizon• Shamrock Farms• 365

Organic Milk Brands – Comparison Table

Organic Valley

Organic Valley, Whole Milk Boxes, Shelf Stable Milk, Healthy Snacks, 6.75oz (Pack of 12)
  • 12 shelf stable, individual organic milk boxes of whole milk (plain) with straw
  • Ultra pasteurized (UHT) dairy milk, with naturally occurring omega-3 and CLA
  • Single serve milk boxes for kids. Perfect for lunch boxes, snacks, and on the go
  • No refrigeration delicious, nutritious, organic milk from pasture-raised cows on small family farms
  • USDA Certified Organic, gluten-free, non GMO, and Kosher with no preservatives, antibiotics, synthetic hormones, rBGH, or rBST. CAUTION – Beware of unauthorized dealers selling Organic Valley. Buy with confidence in our superior quality, warranty, and impeccable customer service when products are ships and sold by Amazon.

Features

Organic Valley states that their products come from happy, pasture grazing cows, aiding in the production of more omega-3s and conjugated linoleic acid in their milk.

They have a regional production model that ensures customers buy fresh, high-quality milk products while supporting their local farmers. They offer four varieties at the 1/2 gallon and gallon size: whole, 2%, 1%, and fat-free. Organic Valley’s milk flavor is described as rich and creamy.

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • Produced by local farmers
  • Available in both gallon and 1/2 gallon
  • Widely available
  • Available on several grocery delivery services (e.g., Amazon, Fresh Direct, and more)

Cons

  • Most expensive gallon

Price

This product can be found in stores and online for around $4.59 per 1/2 gallon and $7.30 per gallon

Clover

Clover Sonoma, Organic 2% Reduced Fat Milk, Gallon, 128 oz

Check Latest Price

Features

Clover is based in Sonoma County, California, and is a third-generation family-owned and operated dairy company. They claim to have “the cleanest milk in all the land.”

Clover works with 19 organic family dairy farms and pays all farmers a premium to meet their quality standards while also donating 5% of its profits to community organizations.

They offer four varieties at the 1/2 gallon and gallon size: whole, 2%, 1%, and fat-free. Clover’s milk flavor is described as unsalted butter, sweet, and fruity.

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • American Grass-fed Certified
  • Produced by local farmers
  • The first U.S. dairy company certified by American Humane Association

Cons

  • Limited availability (West Coast only)
  • Only available in 1/2 gallon
  • Pricier than other options

Price

This product can be found in stores and online for around $4.99 per 1/2 gallon.

Stonyfield Farm

Stonyfield Farm Organic Plain Whole Milk Yogurt, 32 Ounce -- 6 per case.
  • Important - Refrigerated items are perishable and tend to have short shelf lives - some of these can be as little as two weeks from the date of receipt - if you are ordering a large quantity, or are otherwise concerned about expiration dates, consider a frozen product.
  • Ships refrigerated, CANNOT be cancelled after being processed.

Features

Although Stonyfield’s primary product is their yogurt, they also have four different organic kinds of milk on the market: Whole, 2%, 1% and Fat-Free.

Priding themselves as pioneers in the organic movement, Stonyfield promises their milk will never contain toxic pesticides or GMO’s. Not only for the benefit of you, the consumer, but for the benefit of the planet as well.

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • Cheaper than other 1/2 gallon options

Cons

  • Limited availability (North East only)
  • Only available in 1/2 gallon
    • Basic milk taste, with one user describing it as “lunchroom milk.”

Price

This product can be found in stores for around $3.97 per 1/2 gallon.

Horizon

Horizon Organic 1 % Low Fat Milk, 8-Ounce Aseptic Cartons (Pack of 18)
  • Contains 18 single serve milk cartons which are great for lunchboxes, snacks, travel and more, our shelf-stable milk boxes are a perfect alternative to juice boxes.
  • USDA Organic lowfat milk in a delicious chocolate flavor your kids will love
  • 8g protein per serving, excellent source of calcium with 30% DV per serving
  • We're proud to be part of the National Organic Program, which prohibits the use of GMOs

Features

Horizon has the most significant share of the organic milk market. They are also the only milk on this list that is American Grass-fed Certified, meaning they adhere to even stricter standards than the USDA enforces.

They offer four varieties at the 1/2 gallon and gallon size: whole, 2%, 1%, and fat-free. They also provide grass-fed whole milk and 2% at the 1/2 gallon size. Their milk’s flavor is described as buttery and creamy.

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • American Grass-fed Certified
  • Widely available
  • Available on grocery delivery services (e.g., Amazon)

Cons

  • Only available in 1/2 gallon
  • Most expensive

Price

This product can be found in stores and online for around $5.15 per 1/2 gallon.

Shamrock Farms

Shamrock Dairy, Milk Reduced Fat Organic, 96 Fl Oz

Check Latest Price

Features

Shamrock Farms is Arizona’s first USDA certified dairy farm. They claim their “organic milk comes from the cows to your grocery store in less than three days.”

They offer four varieties at the gallon size: whole, 2%, 1%, and fat-free. Their milk’s flavor is described as “farm fresh.”

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • Widely available
    • The gallon bottle is uniquely shaped to fit in a full fridge and be easily used by children.

Cons

  • On the pricier side

Price

This product can be found in stores and online for around $4.39 per 1/2 gallon and $7.10 per gallon.

Trader Joe’s

Trader Joe's Organic Unsweetened Soy Milk
  • Trader Joe'S Organic Unsweetened Soy Milk

Features

There is not much information on this organic milk brand because it is a store-brand, also known as a private-label product.

Although it is one of the more affordable options, there is no way for the consumer to be sure where this milk comes from.

They offer four varieties at the 1/2 gallon and gallon size: whole, 2%, 1%, and fat-free.

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • Cheaper option
  • Unsatisfied? Bring the rest of the product back and receive a full refund, no questions asked

Cons

  • Limited to no information on where the milk comes from
  • Only sold at Trader Joe’s

Price

This product can be found in stores around $3.99 per 1/2 gallon and $5.99 per gallon. Price will vary depending on store location.

365

365 Everyday Value, Organic 1% Milk, 64 oz (Packaging May Vary)

Features

Like Trader Joe’s milk, this organic milk brand is Whole Foods Market’s store-brand product. Although it is one of the more affordable options, there is no way for the consumer to be sure where this milk comes from.

The market’s website states that their milk is “produced by the nation’s leading cooperative of organic family farmers who promote regional farm diversity and economic stability.” They offer four varieties at the 1/2 gallon and gallon size: whole, 2%, 1%, and fat-free.

Pros

  • There are NO antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides or GMO’s
  • Product is certified USDA Organic
  • You can receive a full refund, no questions asked.
  • Widely available

Cons

  • Limited information on the farms the milk comes from

Price

This product can be found in stores and online for around $3.69 per 1/2 gallon and $5.49 per gallon.

via GIPHY

Our Verdict

Although it is on the more expensive side, Organic Valley tops the list of these seven organic milk brands. When it comes to flavor and availability, Organic Valley is the clear winner. Clover is a close second but its flavorful profile wasn’t enough to beat out Organic Valley’s accessible nature.

However, if you’re in a jam or looking to save a dollar, both Trader Joe’s and 365 are both widely available and USDA certified organic (Just don’t expect to be wow-ed in the flavor department).

Milk is no longer just a food staple for children. Both the youth and the elderly enjoy and nourish their bodies with this dairy product. What is even better is that organic milk brands are available now more than ever for our consumption.

Gone are the days of having to worry about consuming cow’s milk laden with antibiotics and reproductive or growth hormones.

So, whether you drink milk straight up or enjoy a splash in your daily coffee or cereal, transitioning from conventional to organic milk can have a positive impact on your health and the environment. With all the options and availability, there is no excuse. Make the change to organic milk today!

Organic chicken breast

You might also like:

The 5 Best Organic Chicken Brands